Thinking about a big cake for a birthday, graduation, or any party? Costco’s sheet cakes are a solid choice – big, cheap, and surprisingly tasty. You don’t need a bakery degree to get a decent looking cake; just follow a few simple steps and you’ll have a sweet centerpiece ready in no time.
First, decide on the size. Costco sells a 12‑inch round, a 9‑inch square, and a full‑sheet option that serves 30‑50 people. The full sheet costs about $20‑$25, which is a steal compared to specialty bakeries. Walk into the bakery department, pick a flavor (chocolate, vanilla, or red velvet are the most common), and tell the staff the date you need it. They’ll ask for a pickup time – usually a few days in advance is safe.
If you’re unsure about the flavor, ask for a sample. The staff often have a small piece you can taste. It’s quick and helps avoid a cake that nobody likes. Also, bring a rough idea of the design – a simple “Happy Birthday Alex” in a basic font works fine. Costco’s bakers aren’t custom‑design artists, but they can pipe letters, add basic sprinkles, or place a simple fondant topper.
Want a personal touch without paying extra? Use your own decorations. Bring edible images, themed candles, or a DIY frosting border. The bakery will gladly place these on the cake for free or a tiny fee. If you need a specific color, ask if they have colored frosting; most locations keep a few basic shades on hand.
Pricing is straightforward. The sheet cake price includes the base flavor and basic frosting. Adding a custom message costs about $5‑$10. Anything beyond that – elaborate fondant, multiple tiers, or special shapes – may not be possible, so keep expectations realistic. For big savings, order the cake a day or two early and pick it up yourself instead of opting for delivery.
One trick many people overlook is buying the cake a week ahead and storing it in the freezer. Wrap it tightly in plastic and a foil layer, then thaw in the fridge the night before your event. This way you lock in the low price and avoid last‑minute rush.
Finally, double‑check the cake’s freshness on pickup. Look for a firm crumb and fresh frosting. If anything seems off, let the staff know right away – they usually replace it without hassle. With these steps, your Costco sheet cake will look good, taste great, and keep your budget happy.
Costco sheet cakes are a popular choice for birthdays and large gatherings, known for their taste and affordability. This article explores how many people a Costco sheet cake can serve, offering practical tips about serving sizes. Discover why these cakes are a favorite, including customization options sure to make your event special.